Measuring for an electric fireplace insert
Measure the firebox opening at the front for width and height, then the depth from the opening to the back wall. Many masonry fireboxes taper toward the back, so measure the rear width too. Choose an electric fireplace insert that fits the smallest of those numbers, with a trim kit or surround wide enough to cover the gap at the front.
The Amantii TRD comes in 26, 30, 38 and 44 inch sizes to match common openings, and the Nuvia ships with a removable trim kit.
Premium inserts and compact models
The higher-priced inserts focus on flame realism and controls. The Napoleon Cineview swaps between log and glass media and has a self-trimming flange. The Amantii TRD has a two-stage heater of up to 5,000 BTU for about 400 square feet. The Dynasty Presto line adds flame and media bed color choices, a heater timer and a crackling sound.
The compact 18, 24 and 36 inch black inserts start near $99. They run on 120V with a heater of about 1,400 watts, and the 24 inch unit measures about 24.2 by 5.1 by 17.5 inches.
Power and the cord route
Most inserts plug into a standard 120V outlet, and few old fireplaces have one inside. Plan the cord route early, and have an electrician add an outlet inside the firebox or beside the hearth if needed. Avoid running a heater on an extension cord.
Close the chimney damper before you set the electric fireplace insert in place. An open flue pulls warm room air up the chimney and lets cold drafts in, which works against the heater. Some owners also fit a chimney balloon or a block-off plate.
Heat output and safety features
An insert is supplemental heat for one room. Most heaters here draw about 1,400 to 1,500 watts, which works out to roughly 4,800 to 5,100 BTU. Coverage figures in listings assume a well-insulated room, so treat them as a best case.
Look for overheat protection, which several models list, plus a thermostat or timer on the remote. The Nuvia adds a plug that monitors its own temperature to guard against overheating, and the Presto line lists blockage protection as well.
Insert or another type of fireplace
An electric fireplace insert makes sense when you already have a firebox and want to stop burning wood without major work. For real flame and more heat, compare gas fireplace inserts, which need a gas line, a chimney liner and a certified installer. For a new wall with no fireplace, a recessed electric fireplace or a wall mounted electric fireplace is the better fit. You can also see all fireplaces in one place.